Cheese APPENZELLER EXTRA, aged 6 months or Aged sheep cheese with hot pepper sauce 50% fat?

Energy 283 kcal 435 kcal
Fat 32 g 38 g
of which saturates 20 g 24,7 g
Carbohydrate 1 g 0,2 g
of which sugars 1 g 0,2 g
Protein 2,5 g 22,8 g
Salt 1,6 g 1,5 g

Figures from the product labels. Green is the better value.

Cheese APPENZELLER EXTRA, aged 6 months
E
Cheese APPENZELLER EXTRA, aged 6 months
283 kcal Fat 32 g Carbs 1 g Prot. 2,5 g
Sat. fat 20 g Sugars 1 g
Aged sheep cheese with hot pepper sauce 50% fat
C
Aged sheep cheese with hot pepper sauce 50% fat
435 kcal Fat 38 g Carbs 0,2 g Prot. 22,8 g
Sat. fat 24,7 g Sugars 0,2 g
150 g