Vanilla flavor ice cream with OREO cookie pieces, 425 ml or Vanilla ice cream with caramel sauce DIONE ZERO, 500ml?

Vanilla flavor ice cream with OREO cookie pieces, 425 ml Vanilla flavor ice cream with OREO cookie pieces, 425 ml D 18 Healthier Vanilla ice cream with caramel sauce DIONE ZERO, 500ml Vanilla ice cream with caramel sauce DIONE ZERO, 500ml D 39

Per 100 g / 100 ml

Energy 236 kcal 183 kcal
Fat 11 g 9,9 g
of which saturates 8,6 g 6,3 g
Carbohydrate 30 g 19,4 g
of which sugars 19 g 5,8 g
Protein 3,7 g 6,2 g
Salt 0,5 g 0,5 g

Figures from the product labels. Green is the better value.

Vanilla flavor ice cream with OREO cookie pieces, 425 ml
D
Vanilla flavor ice cream with OREO cookie pieces, 425 ml
236 kcal Fat 11 g Carbs 30 g Prot. 3,7 g
Sat. fat 8,6 g Sugars 19 g
425 ml
Vanilla ice cream with caramel sauce DIONE ZERO, 500ml
D
Vanilla ice cream with caramel sauce DIONE ZERO, 500ml
183 kcal Fat 9,9 g Carbs 19,4 g Prot. 6,2 g
Sat. fat 6,3 g Sugars 5,8 g
500 g