Vanilla ice cream MAGNUM with caramel, 204ml/168g or VAST Rice + Whey Vanilla Cookie 900 g?

Vanilla ice cream MAGNUM with caramel, 204ml/168g Vanilla ice cream MAGNUM with caramel, 204ml/168g E 0 Healthier VAST Rice + Whey Vanilla Cookie 900 g VAST Rice + Whey Vanilla Cookie 900 g A 86

Per 100 g / 100 ml

Energy 360 kcal 378 kcal
Fat 21 g 2,8 g
of which saturates 12 g 1,7 g
Carbohydrate 38 g 53 g
of which sugars 32 g 2,3 g
Protein 4,9 g 35 g
Salt 0,4 g 0,1 g

Figures from the product labels. Green is the better value.

Vanilla ice cream MAGNUM with caramel, 204ml/168g
E
Vanilla ice cream MAGNUM with caramel, 204ml/168g
360 kcal Fat 21 g Carbs 38 g Prot. 4,9 g
Sat. fat 12 g Sugars 32 g
204 g
VAST Rice + Whey Vanilla Cookie 900 g
A
VAST Rice + Whey Vanilla Cookie 900 g
378 kcal Fat 2,8 g Carbs 53 g Prot. 35 g
Sat. fat 1,7 g Sugars 2,3 g
900 g