Smoked sprats GRAAL, 170 g or Smoked sprats in oil BANGA, 160 g?

Energy 431 kcal 385 kcal
Fat 43 g 36,4 g
of which saturates 4 g 6,4 g
Carbohydrate — 0 g
of which sugars — 0 g
Protein 11 g 14,3 g
Salt 0,3 g 1,6 g

Figures from the product labels. Green is the better value.

Smoked sprats GRAAL, 170 g
Smoked sprats GRAAL, 170 g
431 kcal
Sat. fat 4 g
170 g
Smoked sprats in oil BANGA, 160 g
D
Smoked sprats in oil BANGA, 160 g
385 kcal Fat 36,4 g Carbs 0 g Prot. 14,3 g
Sat. fat 6,4 g Sugars 0 g
160 g