Caramel bar NICKS sweet, 28 g or Bar SALTED CARAMEL FIZI with sweetener, 40 g?

Caramel bar NICKS sweet, 28 g Caramel bar NICKS sweet, 28 g D 18 Healthier Bar SALTED CARAMEL FIZI with sweetener, 40 g Bar SALTED CARAMEL FIZI with sweetener, 40 g D 21

Per 100 g / 100 ml

Energy 387 kcal 381 kcal
Fat 30 g 25,7 g
of which saturates 18 g 13,9 g
Carbohydrate 31 g 39,8 g
of which sugars 9,5 g 1,2 g
Protein 7,4 g 11,5 g
Salt 0,4 g 0,5 g

Figures from the product labels. Green is the better value.

Caramel bar NICKS sweet, 28 g
D
Caramel bar NICKS sweet, 28 g
387 kcal Fat 30 g Carbs 31 g Prot. 7,4 g
Sat. fat 18 g Sugars 9,5 g
28 g
Bar SALTED CARAMEL FIZI with sweetener, 40 g
D
Bar SALTED CARAMEL FIZI with sweetener, 40 g
381 kcal Fat 25,7 g Carbs 39,8 g Prot. 11,5 g
Sat. fat 13,9 g Sugars 1,2 g
40 g